Kansas v. Carr

KANSAS, PETITIONER v. JONATHAN D. CARR
KANSAS, PETITIONER v. REGINALD DEXTER CARR, JR
KANSAS, PETITIONER v. SIDNEY J. GLEASON

Supreme Court of the United States, Scalia, Filed Jan. 20, 2016,
8th Amendment – Mitigation – Jurors need not be instructed that mitigating circumstances “need not be proved beyond a reasonable doubt.”

(Dissent – Sotomayor – because the USSC “often” declines to grant cert where “a state court has wrongly decided an important question of federal law”, this should have been denied. The dissent doesn’t disagree with the court’s actual constitutional holdings, making it an unusual dissent)
Continue reading